Today Thu Fri
It is forcast to be Mostly Cloudy at 10:00 PM EST on February 22, 2012
Mostly Cloudy
6°/0°
It is forcast to be Mostly Cloudy at 10:00 PM EST on February 23, 2012
Mostly Cloudy
6°/1°
It is forcast to be Chance of Rain at 10:00 PM EST on February 24, 2012
Chance of Rain
4°/-1°

20 Comments

news

Building Wall Collapses onto Sidewalk at Yonge and Gould

20100416gouldcollapse_nick1.jpg
Photo by Nick Kozak/Torontoist.


FINAL UPDATE: 6:11 P.M.
At about 12:38 p.m. on Friday afternoon, a section of a building wall above a sushi restaurant collapsed onto Gould Street. (As of 6:11 p.m., there are thankfully no reports of injuries.) Our live coverage, including reports from eyewitnesses inside the restaurant and on the street, and photos just after the collapse from inside and outside, is below.


1:26 P.M.—A story we’re following as it develops (you should follow Torontoist on Twitter @torontoist as we tweet photos and reports): a bit before 1 p.m., the brick wall of the building that houses Tatami Sushi—on Gould, just east of Yonge, right beside Salad King—fell onto the sidewalk below. CityNews initially tweeted that “people may be trapped,” though that’s not what we’re hearing more recently. We’ll be updating this post as we learn more, so stay with us.
1:31 P.M.—

20100416gouldcollapse_1.jpg
Photo by @jamesclee88, taken just after 1 p.m.


1:32 P.M.—Torontoist’s Nick Kozak, on scene, tells us that it’s “Calm. No activity really. The authorities are just observing for now.” The Post is citing “reports” that no-one is trapped, and so we are now reporting on their tweeted report about a report.
1:36 P.M.—We’re waiting for photos from Nick. In the interim, you can see more photos here, here, and, from CityNews, here. CityNews is also reporting “that a sign attached to the wall that collapsed at Yonge/Gould might have pulled it down.” If you have photos or tips, send them to tips@torontoist.com, or tweet @torontoist.
1:50 P.M.—We can glean a good-guess time of the collapse, from Toronto Fire’s Active Incidents board: units were dispatched to the scene at 12:40:05 p.m.
1:54 P.M.—Reader James Agnew was inside Tatami Sushi when the wall fell. Here’s his photo looking out, “about 30 seconds after the wall came down”:

20100416gouldcollapse_2.jpg
Photo by James Agnew.


2:06 P.M.—Nick Warzin sends this photo, from a bit earlier. He has a few more in his Flickr set:

20100416gouldcollapse_3.jpg
Photo by Nick Warzin.


2:11 P.M.—Torontoist’s Nick Kozak sends these photos from about an hour ago.
20100416gouldcollapse_nick2.jpg 20100416gouldcollapse_nick3.jpg

20100416gouldcollapse_nick1.jpg
Photos by Nick Kozak/Torontoist.


According to Torontoist reader Bernie Chang, who was on his way back to work from lunch, and was walking on the north side of Gould, at 12:39 p.m., the wall collapsed just after “3 ladies just finish[ed] walking past….Brinks Security stop and ask if anyone was underneath and warned dazed Sushi restaurant workers to get back in. (Afraid of secondary collapse). Fire and police sirens heard as I was walking back to work.” Adds Chang: “One of the 3 ladies said she [was] ‘going home instead of going back to work’ due to the shock. Someone else suggest[ed] getting a stiff drink!”
2:21 P.M.—Toronto Police have issued a press release, saying that “Yonge Street is closed from Gerrard Street to Dundas Street until further notice.” Their release places the time of the collapse at 12:38 p.m.
2:27 P.M.—And here is one photo from Bernie, showing the scene immediately after the collapse:

20100416gouldcollapse_firstshot_1.jpg
Photo by Bernie Chang


The latest news on injuries is that there are, as yet, none.
2:37 P.M.—Laurie MacDougall Sookraj was also inside the restaurant. She tells us that, right after the fall:

It was pretty scary, we didn’t really know what was going on but there was a ton of dust flooding into the restaurant and there was rubble outside the windows, luckily they didn’t break, we were sitting right next to the windows. We wanted to get out before anything else happened, in case it was all about to collapse but there was confusion about which door to go out and if it was safe outside, so people started going out the door on Gould one at a time carefully over the rubble but it was right under where the bricks had come down so it probably wasn’t the best idea, but everyone got out ok and it sounds like no one was hurt outside so I guess it all went as well as could be expected. We’re still feeling pretty unnerved about the whole thing. Nobody wants to die at lunch.

2:59 P.M.—Now the question is how it happened in the first place. The Globe/CP’s report points to a large, ten-by-eight-metre sign, which a worker said “had been installed on the facade and began leaning toward the street”; the Star, though, talked to an eyewitness who cited no sign, saying instead that “It just looked like a loose brick that came out of place, but then gradually, a bunch of them just kept falling.” From a look at the rubble, we can see pieces of the faux windows that lined the building, but nothing larger—though of course we can’t know what we can’t see beneath the bricks.
3:36 P.M.—Now it’s beginning to sound like the sign, which ran along the bottom of the section that fell, was not apparently responsible for the collapse. Bernie Chang (who we’ve been talking to about the collapse since shortly after it happened), tells us that, from what he could tell, “it was only the double brick wall and the windows and frames that fell down, taking the Tatami Restaurant sign underneath down too.” Chang watched the tail end of the fall: “I heard a rumble, then turn[ed] to the building, a second later the layer of lower bricks on the second floor bulge[d] and all the bricks above slid down.”
6:11 P.M.—A final update, and a small correction: while we first called the restaurant that the wall fell in front of “Sushi Tatami,” it’s more correctly Tatami Sushi. (We’ve made the change to earlier updates, above.) Most importantly, the Star is now reporting, conclusively, that “nobody was hurt in the incident”—though it’s still not clear what caused the collapse.
For now, we’ll leave you with this shot, by Torontoist Flickr pool photographer PJMixer, of firefighters surveying the damage to the building on the south side of Gould earlier today—while across the street, at the site that once held Sam the Record Man, the results of a much more controlled demolition sit.

20100416gouldcollapse_final.jpg
Photo by PJMixer from the Torontoist Flickr Pool.

Filed under: , , , ,

Report error Send a tip

Comments

  • http://undefined james a

    My coworkers and I were sitting literally just inside the window under that wall. Holy crap that was scary!

  • http://undefined Chris Orbz

    Police training must honestly be half learning to yell “PLEASE STEP BACK, EVERYONE PLEASE GET BACK!” when everyone is standing around.
    Either this guy’s a pro, or he’s indicating “We dunno WTF dude, we just got here, we were just enjoying our bike ride.”

  • tapesonthefloor

    A few high-res non-cell-phone shots:
    http://bit.ly/9Jdp0p
    I really hope everyone is okay. Official word so far from police and fire is still “no statement”.

  • http://undefined Usus

    I had no idea the windows were fake.

  • http://undefined Robsonian

    here’s hoping this doesn’t mean the whole building has to come down. I suspect it will.

  • David Toronto

    I hate to think this will be the end of the old Edison Hotel. It’s suffered enough indignities from all the ground floor merchants who have no thought about the
    historical elements of the building and proceed willy-nilly to strip it of its architectural glory.
    Had someone shown more thought and care back in the ’70s or ’80s, this might not have happened.

  • http://undefined thelemur

    Does anyone know what the sign was? Google Maps shows that area when Tatami was still a shoe store that had gone out of business, and no sign yet.

  • tapesonthefloor

    My initial reaction is to say: No building that contributes so strongly to the streetscape of one of Canada’s most famous roads will be torn down so carelessly, but then I look across to the north side of Gould and I shut my mouth.

  • http://undefined Robsonian

    but hold the phone! Laid open as it presently is, it’s clear this building has been more than substantially renovated anyhow. Maybe not then.

  • Dry Brain

    I don’t imagine the building will have to be demolished. It looks like a really localized collapse–I think the CityNews info may be right (that the big Tatami Sushi sign was improperly affixed or was too heavy, and pulled the facade off.)

  • http://undefined Usus

    I believe the Tatami Sushi sign ran all the way across. I don’t think there was a sign above. It may have been that sign that put too much strain on it because it was only installed in the last month or so.

  • http://undefined Ari

    Google map street view of this intersection with the wall intact: http://bit.ly/ah7PTD

  • http://undefined Vincent Clement

    The sign face may have been installed in the last month or so, but the sign box (frame, lighting and wiring) has been there for some time.

  • http://undefined James Goneaux

    Reminds me of the “Cheers Tavern” collapse, the cause of which is still a mystery (at least to me…I guess the Star, etc., is too busy chasing scandal).
    http://www.flickr.com/photos/10212406@N06/sets/72157603705233676/

  • http://www.torontocitylife.com/ torontocitylife
  • http://undefined harald

    There are two layers of brick, as you can see. If you look closely, the outer layer of brick is only half-supported by that large steel beam* holding everything up; it wouldn’t have taken much to shift the whole outer layer off the support – after which gravity wins.
    (*not the wimpy sign frame; there’s a full steel i-beam behind it, running the length of the building, holding up the outer wall and the second floor.)
    I’m not an engineer, but as far as I can tell, the only thing holding up a large section of the third floor is that exposed steel-stud wall, which isn’t designed to hold that kind of load. They’ll have to figure out some way to shore things up before the rest of the building collapses…

  • W. K. Lis

    The war on bicycles continue. Bricks fall on bicycles parked on sidewalk, damaging some.

  • http://www.torontocitylife.com/ torontocitylife
  • http://undefined Ronnie

    Please feel free to check out my flickr set on the collapse:
    http://www.flickr.com/photos/ronnieyip/show/

  • http://undefined Jack

    This kind of thing was mentioned on TorontoNews24.com last week about our building getting old in the downtown area. Here’s the link to the story. We need these buildings inspected.
    http://bit.ly/czku72