Tip Us Off
E-mail us with news tips, discoveries, story ideas, and anything else cool.
Advertisements

About Torontoist

Torontoist is a website about Toronto and everything that happens in it. More about us.

Editor-in-Chief: DAVID TOPPING

Publisher: GOTHAMIST

What's On Today
Check out Torontoist's daily event listings
Recent Comments

ReluctantTorontonian on TIFF 2008: Preview

Toby von Meistersinger on The Voice Of The Game

eller on The Urbanaut

ambrose on ROAWR...Pop!

wardnikoff on The Voice Of The Game

tyrannosaurus_rek on ROAWR...Pop!

wardnikoff on ROAWR...Pop!

Robin Sharp on Fauxbama

David Topping on Hot and Bothered

tyrannosaurus_rek on Hot and Bothered

The Tall Poppy Interview
Favourites

November 29, 2007

Because the Real Toronto Isn't Ugly Enough?

2007_11_29Streets_to.gif

At Torontoist, we spend a lot of time worrying about whether or not Toronto is ugly. We fret about bad buildings, inappropriate signage, and street furniture, but this is the first time we've gone out of our way to call-out a website for contributing to Toronto's ugliness.

Streets.to uses the tag line "Toronto's Visual Search Engine," and setting aside the fact that there's no way to actually search this site (other than navigating through pull-down menus), you have to be impressed with the amount of work that's gone into this thing. For some reason, they have taken dozens of Toronto's top venues and painstakingly turned them into Flash animations. The question is: why?

Why would you want to turn Toronto's streetscape into something that looks like it came out of Leisure Suit Larry, circa 1996 (see below)?

The really strange part of the whole streets.to experience is that once you actually navigate through to get to the inside of a venue, you are presented with very classy full-colour photographs. So why make users go through multiple screens of ugliness before presenting them with the information they might want? Why go through all the trouble of creating an entire Flash universe when photographs are obviously so superior? We don't get it.

Obviously advertisers seem to like the idea, based on the number of places that have signed up to be converted in Leisure Suit Larry mode, but it's hard to believe that the site will gain much traffic from real users while it insists on being such an assault on the eyes.

NOTE: This article originally blamed a restricted colour palette in Flash for the ugliness of the animations. As it turns out, Flash isn't to blame at all, the animations are ugly without any help.

2007_11_29LLL_vs_streets_to.gif


Email This Entry







Advertisement: Torontoist Continues Below!

Comments (7)

Hopefully they will take all of that painstaking animation and turn it into an old-school Lucasarts adventure game. Something like Sam & Max: Freelance Urban Activists, or Day of the OMB Tentacle.

 

Err... Flash is not restricted to 216 colours.

 

"Err... Flash is not restricted to 216 colours."

doh!

 

It's true that flash isn't restricted to 216 colours. I should also point out that I myself haven't used Flash in a couple of years. The standard websafe palette was certainly enabled by default at that time though, in fact, here's a little article on how to get around the default colour palette in flash:
http://www.peachpit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=169707&rl=1

That said, on closer inspection the images on the site do seem to using a more robust palette. That doesn't change the fact that they're still ugly however. I'll change the article to reflect the use of a more robust palette.

 

+++points for Leisure Suit Larry references!

 

User experience aside, Flash is also horrible for search engines, so they're not helping themselves in terms of getting free SE traffic...

 

it's interesting how all your posts come back to the same thread...in one way or another...and that is "toronto the ugly"...i think we are the only place in the WHOLE WIDE WORLD where a crystal and aluminium siding have ever been blended together....

 
Post a comment (Comment Policy)

2003-2008 Gothamist LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. We use MovableType.