Supreme Court Lets Toronto's Billboard Tax Stand
Torontoist has been acquired by Daily Hive Toronto - Your City. Now. Click here to learn more.




Supreme Court Lets Toronto’s Billboard Tax Stand

The City can collect its due from outdoor-ad companies.

It looks like billboard owners will have to pay up. Photo by {a href=""}416Pictures{/a}, from the {a href=""}Torontoist Flickr Pool{/a}.

The Supreme Court of Canada announced today that it’s rejecting a hard-fought legal challenge to Toronto’s billboard tax, meaning the City can continue collecting money from owners of outdoor advertising.

The tax, instituted in 2009 after years of campaigning by activists, dings owners of outdoor ads for annual payments to the City. Billboard companies began suing the City in 2010. Their argument was that levying the billboard tax exceeded the City’s legal authority for a few reasons. According to the Globe, the City hasn’t been collecting the tax during the legal challenge.

This is the latest development in a multi-year fight. In 2011, the companies lost the case, but won an all-important exemption for billboards erected before the tax’s effective date. Then, an appeals court overturned the exemption. Now, the Supreme Court has said that it won’t hear a further appeal of the case. There’s no higher court to hear yet another appeal, so barring any extraordinary shenanigans, this legal wrangling is done.

In 2009, City staff estimated that the tax would bring in $10.4 million per year.

CORRECTION: Novemver 22, 2012, 2:15 PM This post originally cited a Globe and Mail article that claims that the City hasn’t been collecting the billboard tax because of legal action by the billboard industry. A City spokesperson has since told us this is not the case.