"A City Divided" is a City Susceptible To Gun Violence
Torontoist has been acquired by Daily Hive Toronto - Your City. Now. Click here to learn more.




“A City Divided” is a City Susceptible To Gun Violence

A vigil for the Eaton Centre shooting brings out passionate pleas for support for low-income neighborhoods in Toronto.

The crowd yesterday at a vigil at Yonge-Dundas Square. Photo by Bronwyn Kienapple/Torontoist.

Huddled under the red umbrellas of Yonge-Dundas Square, a small crowd gathered in the pouring rain last night, as community leaders spoke their minds about gun violence. Named a “Vigil for a United Gun-Free Toronto” and organized by city councillor Kristyn Wong-Tam (Ward 27, Toronto Centre-Rosedale), yesterday’s gathering was in direct response to the Eaton Centre shooting that took place earlier this month, but also spoke to broader concerns about gun violence in Toronto.

The speakers were emotional as they discussed the need for job opportunities, social support, stricter gun laws, and an end to the perception by many Canadians that gun violence is mostly the problem of a remote, “other” population.

Colleen Lavallée, a resident of Alexandra Park, repeatedly choked up as she talked about the children from her community who’ve given up because they don’t have any choices. “The monsters that you read about in the paper, we see them before they become like that,” said Lavallee. “We lost them before they picked up a gun. Everyone watched, and nobody said anything.”

Community activist Kofi Hope spoke to a lack of hope, of a population in Toronto that feels so disconnected that they turn to gangs, guns, and drugs to feel empowered. “We are slowly becoming a city divided,” he said. “A city divided between a wonderful middle-class world of gleaming towers and a vibrant downtown and a city of tower blocks filled with the working poor and visible minorities who feel more and more disconnected from the rest of the city.”

The consequences are real and heartrending–speaker Elaine Lumley lost her only son to gun violence. She advocated for tighter gun control, decried the end of the long-gun registry, and also warned the audience that the shooting at the Eaton Centre should be a wake-up call to Torontonians regarding the gun violence that has long existed in this city.

Hani Afrah, who lives in Regent Park, agreed with Lumley. “It’s really sad that this happened in the Eaton Centre, but it happens all the time in my neighborhood,” she said. She and her brother Ismail (who are students at George Brown and U of T respectively) both agreed that social programs, especially mentoring opportunities and job assistance for youth with a criminal record, are crucial to combating the disenfranchisement that leads to violence.

Ismail Afrah also pointed out that while Canada provides services like welfare and both primary and secondary education, creating a healthy community in Regent Park and other low-income neighborhoods depends on more than just meeting basic needs.

“Canada allows people to subsist,” said Ismail Afrah. “But, people need to live.”