Today Tuesday Wednesday
It is forcast to be Thunderstorm at 10:00 PM CDT on May 20, 2013
Thunderstorm
88°/68°
It is forcast to be Thunderstorm at 10:00 PM CDT on May 21, 2013
Thunderstorm
84°/64°
It is forcast to be Chance of a Thunderstorm at 10:00 PM CDT on May 22, 2013
Chance of a Thunderstorm
79°/59°

19 Comments

news

One Day, and Night, at City Hall

20110728exec1.jpg
Overflow seating for today’s Executive Committee meeting, set up in the City Hall rotunda. Photo by Hamutal Dotan/Torontoist.


Something remarkable happened in the last 24 hours at City Hall. Against precedent, expectation, and circadian rhythms, hundreds of Torontonians stayed up last night, all night, to have their voices heard at City Hall. They did this knowing that the mayor, who was chairing the epic Executive Committee meeting about a long list of budget cuts the City is considering, wasn’t inclined to be convinced. They did this after the mayor’s brother, Councillor Doug Ford (Ward 2, Etobicoke North), proclaimed “Ford Nation is too busy working, paying taxes, creating jobs,” to come and depute at City Hall.
This left—who?—the lazy and unemployed, in Doug’s estimation, to address the seat of government in Toronto.
If the intention in deciding to keep the meeting running overnight was to wear the deputants out, thin their numbers, and otherwise mitigate the opposition to the service cuts council will soon decide on, it backfired. Residents weren’t having it. Of the approximately 200 who spoke, just three encouraged any kind of service cut; the rest said some form of “raise my taxes, but keep our City intact.”
It is too soon to tell what effect last night will have on Ford’s mayoralty. But it is not too soon to say: this was an unprecedented show of of engagement at City Hall—literally, the longest meeting on record. It will prove a watershed in the collective memory of grassroots activists in Toronto. Not because they did such a good job organizing that they got people to the meeting, but because so many of the deputants had never come to City Hall before, never spoken at a meeting, much less stayed up all night to do so. Because when the committee voted to cut their speaking time, they stayed. Because when the meeting hit its 12- and then its 20-hour mark, they stayed. Because new people kept arriving, even at 3 a.m. Because they brought pies and coffee and mouthwash for those who had been at City Hall all day. It was the most important slumber party held in Toronto in years.
And Ford Nation, though invited, declined to attend.
To read a full recap of the Executive Committee meeting, head right here.

Filed under: , , ,

Report error Send a tip

Comments

  • chrisoftoronto

    Ford Nation declined to attend, because they're not engaged. You say, “tax cuts are good” and they'll nod, and that's it. I've seen comments on newspapers where they say “oh, I went to work, then I went home, and I cooked dinner, then I played with my kid, then I watched some TV”. If you were truly interested you'd juggle your schedule and get downtown.

    That's why the so-called “special interest groups”  – and in a way we are, in that we use and like the city services -  are the ones that speak. We're the ones who are passionate about our city and care enough to go and sit in City Hall at 4 o'clock on a Friday Morning.

    The so-called “silent majority” are silent because they are generally apathetic towards the cause. Getting that $60 back was nice, but that's the limit of their interest.

    Of course, the Fords are aware of this, and raise the spectre of the Union boogeyman stacking City hall (at the same time inviting Ford Nation out to stack it the opposite way). That's all it is, is boogeymen.

    My hope is that enough Ford Nation councillors are swayed by this to change the course of the mayoralty. There are still half a dozen, maybe even a dozen hardliners but the reality is the Stintzes and the Minnan-Wongs of the world are also interested in re-election and if/when it becomes obvious staying with Ford Nation hurts their chances, they'll leap.

  • istoronto

    Ford Nation, is comprised of people who couldn't care less about anything, but the thickness of their wallet. They're the first to complain about street festivals closing down roads, about dogs and children running amuck in “their” park, about parking costs downtown and street litter as they throw a Tim Horton's cup on to the sidewalk. They are disengaged and care little about anything that doesn't effect them personally. The reason they didn't show at the meeting was because they really don't give a shit. I don't think there are that many of them anyway. “Ford Nation” I don't think so. “Ford Notion” is probably more accurate.

  • http://paul.kishimoto.name Paul Kishimoto

    “Ford Notion”—brilliant!

  • David Toronto

    That comment by Doug Ford about people being too busy working, etc., is
    exactly what the parrots at CFRB and Giorgio Mammoliti have been saying.
    So, they memorised talking points from a crib sheet.  

    Not an original thought among them which is a pity because
    Toronto deserves better.

  • Yeould

    The meeting!

    Good: So very uplifting to see so many people speak so passionately about the city services that make this place worth living in in the first place. And you know what, it was just absolutely touching to hear person after person say they'd be willing to pay more taxes if it ends up benefiting society as a whole, i mean just think about that for a second. As someone on the, erm, lower end of the income scale (i'm an artist, go figure), to know that there are people out there willing to sacrifice a little bit just because it's the Right Thing To Do is just amazing, frankly. Like, seriously. I feel really good about this city right now.

    Bad: Would have liked to see more high-profile artists come out to defend the arts (although i missed the last 4 hours so maybe they were all packed in there). I wasn't expecting margaret atwood herself to turn up, but a few recognizable names would have been nice. Probably just a pet peeve of mine though.

    Good: Learned so much about city council today, learned people's names and their attitudes as well, followed along with that online list of how everyone has voted so far (thanks, Torontoist!) and just generally became more engaged in the whole process. Wouldn't have happened under an actually good Mayor, ironically, so thanks to fob rord or whatever his name is for being so antagonistic as to get people to take notice.

    Bad: Didn't hear a single question from the aforementioned “mayor.” I mean why even show up? Why even get out of bed? Plus his demeanor is precisely that of a stereotypical elementary school substitute teacher (“SORRY IF I'M GETTING YOUR NAMES WRONG”) which is sort of too terrifying to be funny.

    Good: Anyone notice how many of the speaker were women?? How many of the people running important programs and arts boards and historical societies are women? So very many women, and so very uplifting to see. Was impressed x10 with the women on city council too, i mean we've got some seriously great female role models in this city, and this needs to be mentioned more often. Really, really pleased and impressed.

    Bad: This Mammoliti guy is just beyond the pale, i mean every word out of his mouth is just some disingenuous, venom-laced barrage of ignorance. Like, was he on day release or what? Seriously, this man needs to be ignored for all time, because he's clearly some kind of borderline sociopath who hates everyone and everything that's not like him. You'd think that at least a rudimentary ability to work with other people would be a prerequisite for being in government, but this man has so little empathy rolling around in his diseased head that it's frankly just scary. Here's to a few decades from now, when he's a lonely, bitter old man who can't figure out why he has no friends and his family never visits. And to the ford nation in general (and i'm paraphrasing The Social Network here): people don't hate you because you're conservatives, they hate you because you're Assholes. Period.

    Good: Thanks again to the Torontoist for the full coverage and live blogging and links to the online live stream! High five in your general direction, and looking forward to more such coverage as the ford regime continues its inevitable slide into the cartoonish self-destruction that will be the inevitable result of pretending you're governing a different city than you actually are.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=633316162 Larry Till

    Huzzah to all those who contributed to this exercise – the deputants, observers, journalists and, yes, councillors – for sticking around til the bitter end. Those who whine about apathy need only look to your example to refute their bogus claim.

  • istoronto

    Ford and Mammoliti's relationship reminds me of Spike and Chester the dogs from the WB cartoons? Here is a link for those that are not familiar with them. http://youtu.be/ov-1S8Xxd94

  • istoronto

    Or maybe it's more like this http://youtu.be/OogLnq0tkOI

  • http://twitter.com/tapesonthefloor tapesonthefloor

    “I don't think there are that many of them anyway”

    The idea that “Ford Nation” was a genuine grassroots uprising last year was largely the result of the Toronto Sun and some clever use of the internet leading up to the election (read: astroturfing).

    Though you'll have no problems finding people who will always vote for the “lower taxes candidate” and who still think Don Cherry gave the fruity downtowners a much-deserved ass-kicking that day not long ago, the idea that the city is rich with informed advocates of reduced public services is absurd. Frankly, it's a bit of an oxymoron.

  • Jacob

    The term “silent majority” is a load of BS, anyway. This singled-minded bloc, unified in agreement, is a fairy tale brought up by people of unbounded faith in the own opinions. Placing one's opinion in the mouths of everyone who does not speak is the height of arrogance.

    The only thing the silent majority has is common is that they're silent. They hold a wide variety of opinions, and are silent for many reasons. Some are silent because they agree with who is in power and therefore don't feel the need to speak up, some are silent because they are apathetic and couldn't be bothered to speak, some are silent because they're scared of others knowing their opinion… but a great many are silent because they think their voice will not be heard.

  • EC_Confidential

    I'd love to know how many of the deputations were from outside of the downtown core – like that sobbing 14 year-old girl from Scarborough who stayed up way late and overcame her fear of public speaking just because she wanted to save her library.

    These assholes keep trying to make this a 'downtown' vs. 'suburban' issue, when in fact it's just plain old-fashioned class warfare – with a few gratuitous shots at the 'artsy gala crowd' to make themselves sound like Joe Lunchbucket.

  • adamd1

    You are reading my mind!

    Likewise @Yeould:disqus on Mammolit. He wants a floating casino. He wants a red-light district on the Toronto Islands. He thinks that someone calling out Rob Ford for using his cellphone while driving is trying to insite “road rage”.

    What is he seven years old? I mean we all wanted to be astronauts or something at some point but we all, you know, *grew up* and recognized what reality was. This guy leaps to ridiculous conclusions and seemingly has no communicational skills.

    And people got him elected!

    I semi-eagerly await the results of this whole thing, which for the moment I assume will be Ford and crew just ignoring the whole thing and doing what they were going to do anyway.

  • Amanda B

    What a fantastic description of the silent majority! Do you mind if I cross-post it to FB, crediting you of course?

  • http://twitter.com/tapesonthefloor tapesonthefloor

    “Would have liked to see more high-profile artists come out to defend the arts”

    We should have asked them directly! Start sending emails now. This process will be repeated in September, and if you ask nicely and with plenty of notice you may get your wish.

  • Jacob

    Go right ahead.

  • Yeould

    Agreed! That is an excellent idea, and I'm gonna challenge myself to do just that…

  • http://liannesentar.livejournal.com/ Lianne

    I'm pretty sure Margaret Atwood was simply out of town. She probably would have been there, otherwise.

  • http://openid.anonymity.com/5ysEHU3eJ Jacob

    LOL LOLOLOLO

    You said it is arrogant to put the one's opinion into the mouth of others, yet when you describe the reason why the silent majority is being silent you are doing the same thing. Are you not? You are using your opinion of why they are silent as if it is their reason for their silence. so instead of speaking for collective, however imaginary, you decided you can start providing us with their rational?

    oh the irony.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=172004407 Indro Bhattacharyya

    What's fascinating to me about Mammoliti is that it appears he's earned his living off the taxpayers most of his working. Including being a union member and president (!). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G… To me, his vitriol is disingenuous as best, sociopathic at worst. After exec committee I'm really curious about the people that live in his ward and return him to office time and time again.

Weather forecast by WP Wunderground & Denver Snow Service