Today Thu Fri
It is forecast to be Thunderstorm at 11:00 PM EDT on July 30, 2014
Thunderstorm
24°/15°
It is forecast to be Chance of Rain at 11:00 PM EDT on July 31, 2014
Chance of Rain
23°/16°
It is forecast to be Chance of a Thunderstorm at 11:00 PM EDT on August 01, 2014
Chance of a Thunderstorm
25°/17°

1 Comment

news

2010 Villain: Blaming Pedestrians

201012-heroesandvillains-villain-blamingpedestrians.jpg
Illustration by Matthew Daley/Torontoist.


Torontoist is ending the year by naming our Heroes and Villains—Toronto’s very best and very worst people, places, and things over the past twelve months. From December 13–17: the Villains! From December 20–24, the Heroes! And, from December 27–30, you can vote for Toronto’s Superhero and Supervillain of the year.


Like clockwork, every year, pedestrian injuries peak in winter and early summer. In fact, we’re likely just coming down from one such peak right now—the switch back from Daylight Savings Time has been blamed for triggering it. But January of this year saw a much worse rash of traffic collisions, which at one point killed ten pedestrians in eight days. The police response? A widely publicized “pedestrian blitz” that handed out tickets for jaywalking, which in many cases is not, in fact, an offense.
For one reason or another, pedestrians end up bearing the brunt of public scorn for collisions. In the typical absence of conclusive evidence of fault, it’s all too easy to write off collisions by deciding, as the Star’s Christopher Hume put it, that “pedestrians are naughty children who must be protected from themselves.”
What we’re not asking is why we tolerate so much danger on our city streets, and so little action to against it. Especially when everyone, from the Shawn Micallefs to the Don Cherrys of the world, is a pedestrian sometimes.
For three years in a row now—2008 [PDF], 2009 [PDF], and the first quarter of 2010 (no newer statistics were available) [PDF]—Toronto has had more traffic collisions per 100,000 people than any other city in Canada. On average, 2,220 pedestrians are struck in reported collisions every year, of which only one hundred escaped unharmed. Typically, twenty-eight victims die, but this year, fourteen died in January alone—a record-breaking number of fatalities clustered in central Toronto. The city’s latest official statistics [PDF] show that only twelve percent of injury victims were ruled to have been “inattentive” at the time of a collision, a percentage that has remained virtually unchanged since 2004 [PDF]. Vastly more often than not, pedestrian victims were in a normal, attentive state, had the right of way, and were crossing in good road conditions.
Unfortunately, pedestrian victims have few natural defenders. In discussions about traffic safety they tend to get lumped in with cyclists, which dooms things for several reasons. Being mentally filed alongside cyclists doesn’t actually give pedestrian victims any dedicated representation, for starters, and the two groups have different (though sometimes related) needs, and use different parts of the roadway altogether. Moreover, this puts pedestrians squarely in the crossfire of the so-called “War on the Car.” Furthermore, while Toronto police generally make great efforts to warn against rushing to lay blame (this year’s pedestrian blitz aside), this strategy can easily backfire. In a climate where conventional wisdom—not to mention mainstream media—hold that pedestrians struck in traffic weren’t adequately protecting themselves, a well-intentioned neutral stance enables commonplace biases towards assuming that dead or injured pedestrians were to blame for their own misfortune.
Ultimately, the situation is alarmingly counter-productive. Because pedestrian injuries and deaths seem to be translated instantly into anecdotal evidence of non-drivers’ carelessness, public attention is diverted from the need to address systemic road safety problems, glossing over the role of infrastructure in promoting or undermining pedestrian safety, and broadcasting an everyone-for-themselves mentality incompatible with the life of healthy communities. The sad results are dangerous roads that stay dangerous, year after year.

Comments

  • http://undefined Michael

    We like to blame everyone else for everything, it absolves us (at least in our minds) of responsibility. I will make my main point first. As with the cyclists vs car debate we all need to take collective responsibility for our own safety and the safety of others, regardless of your chosen mode of transportation. I know that some would argue that people are responsible for their own safety and if a pedestrian blithely walks out on to a street without taking precautions and is hit by a car, or a bicycle for that matter it is their own damn fault. I say if this attitude describes you, then on some levels you are a poor citizen.
    As a motorist, cyclist (though rarely these days) and a pedestrian I do think that there is generally an expectation amongst pedestrians that as soon as you set foot in the street all traffic must halt and avoid you at all cost. I too felt this way until I spent a few years living in another country. Physics aside I can tell you that this attitude will get you killed in almost every other major city in the world. Try it in London and you will die quickly; New York, same outcome; Montreal, I dare you. I j-walk a lot, more than I should. If I get hit by anything in the road then really I have no one to blame but myself. However, if I get hit in a cross walk or any other place where I truly have the right of way then brother, it’s really not my fault, providing of course I wasn’t just walking head down, texting, just accepting that if I see the little man on the traffic lights I am safe, etc.
    In London, the same motorist who would have gladly run you down when you j-walk will, with total certainty respect your rights as a pedestrian if you are walking where and when you should. This happens because they do a much better job of training drivers in places like the UK than we do in Canada, but more importantly, there is a better appreciation on all sides of a collective responsibility.
    We all need to take responsibility for our own behaviour and actions. Motorists, slow down and respect pedestrians and cyclists. Pedestrians and cyclists, remember that cars don’t maneuver or stop as quickly as you can, and pedestrians, we have to accept that just because a little man on a light says we can go doesn’t mean it is safe to do so.
    When did I turn in to my mother?
    Michael Banani