Today Fri Sat
It is forcast to be Fog at 11:00 PM EDT on May 24, 2012
Fog
29°/18°
It is forcast to be Chance of Rain at 11:00 PM EDT on May 25, 2012
Chance of Rain
28°/18°
It is forcast to be Overcast at 11:00 PM EDT on May 26, 2012
Overcast
27°/15°

39 Comments

news

Dufferin is Jogging Away From Its Past

20100124lookingeastonqueen.jpg
A rendering of what the completed Dufferin Street underpass will look like from the southwest corner of Dufferin Street and Queen Street West.


For more than a century, Dufferin Street’s detour along Peel and Gladstone avenues—commonly known as the Dufferin Jog—has been a defining feature of West Queen West, and an ever-growing nuisance for vehicles (especially TTC buses), nearby residents, and developers. The jog first came into existence in 1884, when Dufferin Street was cut in half to make room for the railway lines that currently run over Queen Street West. Since 1966, the City has had plans on the books to eliminate the jog, but the Dufferin Street underpass was only given the go-ahead recently due in part to West Queen West’s redevelopment.
Torontoist stopped by the construction site last weekend, as engineers were lifting the bridges to their new height, and later had the opportunity to talk with Jim Schaffner, senior project engineer at the City’s Structures and Expressways Department, about the final stages of the forty-million-dollar project.


20100124dufferinlookingnorthintotunnel.jpg
A rendering of what the completed project will look like from the south side of Dufferin Street.


“The work we’re doing at the moment is to construct an underpass underneath the rail lines to connect Dufferin Street on the north side of Queen Street to the south side of Queen Street,” explained Schaffner. “Stage one of the work was to move the rail tracks to the south side of the site, divert the rail traffic to the south, and then construct the north half of the underpass. That stage of the work is now complete. We’ve flipped the tracks over, so the tracks are now on the north side of the newly completed underpass, and we’re now working on the south side.”
20100124dufferinbefore.jpg

20100124dufferinafter.jpg
The bridges, before and after they were raised by hydraulic jacks. Photos by Remi Carreiro/Torontoist.


Over the weekend, workers used hydraulic jacks to raise the bridges about a metre—the clearance necessary to connect the new underpass with Queen Street West. The rail lines that run over the bridges have been removed and will now stay out of service until the project is complete.
“I’m thrilled that the project is finally underway,” Ward 18 Councillor, TTC Chair, and mayoral candidate Adam Giambrone told Torontoist. “The community will benefit from this project through improved transit service, better traffic flow, as well as improved safety conditions for both pedestrians and cyclists. Regarding transit, yes there will be improvement to the Dufferin bus route, but it is also worth noting that the Queen streetcar route will also experience some improvement. Both routes will be able to clear this intersection faster than they can currently.”

20100124lookingsouthondufferin.jpg
An overhead view of the final project.


The Dufferin underpass is also being designed to accommodate streetcar tracks. But as Danny Nicholson, the TTC’s corporate communications supervisor, told us, “there are no current plans to build tracks through the underpass.”
Of course, no City of Toronto project is complete these days without provisions for a public art display and additional green space, so accordingly, the underpass will feature trippy tie-dyed mosaic art by Luis Jacob, the winner of last year’s public art competition for the space, and an amphitheatre-style park on the north side of the intersection.

20100124theendofdufferin.jpg
A photo of Dufferin Street and Queen Street West, 1897. City of Toronto Archives, Fonds 200, Series 376, File 2, Item 10.


Like many of Toronto’s current transit headaches, the jog is a relic of the days when railway companies dictated policy to the city with impunity, snapped up all the best lands for their use, and divided communities with little regard for their inhabitants. “Parkdale and West Queen West are really neat, but there’s this dead space between them,” Councillor Gord Perks (Ward 14, Parkdale-High Park) told us. “I think this is going to connect them and make them just one continuous and lovely place.”
The City plans to break through the wall on the north side of Queen Street West in February and hopes to have the project complete by July 2010.
All renderings courtesy of Delcan [PDF].

CORRECTION: JANUARY 27, 2010 The first rendering in this post is from the vantage point of the southwest corner of Queen and Dufferin, not the northwest corner as originally stated.

Comments

  • http://undefined Darren

    Nice…too bad they couldnt plan this along with the DRL seeing how many projections of the DRL show it as either beside the tracks or under Queen, ie at that intersection for sure. Same with the Pape Station reno.

  • http://undefined Darren

    I think the caption for the second picture is incorrect. How can that be Dufferin Street and with streetcar tracks? Shouldnt that be either the west or east of Queen?

  • smasharts

    The 2nd photo caption is correct – it is the 1rst photo which has the incorrect caption – it should say “… from the southwest corner of Dufferin Street and Queen Street West.” The 2nd photo shows the streetcar tracks which come up along Dufferin to Queen from the CNE; the Queen tracks are hard to see in the photo.

  • http://undefined Tlönista

    Yay! I live right in the neighbourhood and am thrilled you did an article on this. That bit of the road just clogs everything up during rush hour. And there’s inevitably a lot of verrrry slow and careful manoeuvring required whenever the 29 northbound has to make that first right turn!

  • http://undefined Darren

    Yes, you are correct. Thanks.

  • http://theintrepid.blogspot.com/ Stephen Michalowicz

    You’re right. The first caption is incorrect. I’ll fix that now.

  • Hamutal Dotan

    Thanks for catching this! We’ve updated the caption and appended a correction notice to the post.

  • http://undefined Martin Reis

    Damn the jog! Full speed ahead! Like Dufferin isn’t scary enough. Another job for Pantalone’s gang.

  • Mark Ostler

    ???
    The Dufferin Jog straddles Wards 14 and 18. Perks and Giambrone, respectively. Are they henchmen in Pantalone’s gang? Not sure what the deputy mayor has to do with the jog.

  • http://undefined Darren

    All 3 are tripping over themselves to soak up as much limelight as possible. If humans were distinctly related to leeches, those 3 would be prime examples.

  • rek

    That first photo immediately reminded me of Seoul’s hidden underground art gallery at Cheonggyecheon stream, build under the road and bridge.

  • http://undefined W. K. Lis

    Too bad they don’t seem to be putting in streetcar tracks between Dundas Street and Queen Street. Would have been a good time to do it as well.

  • http://undefined rich1299

    I love it! I’m sure it will help move traffic through that area much more quickly. I had seen the ongoing construction for many months but had no idea what it was for, I wish these sorts of projects would put up signs letting us know what they’re doing and what the finished product will look like, I get curious when I see all that work going on and don’t know why, mind you it can be fun trying to guess what they might be doing but still I’d like to see a billboard showing it instead.

  • http://undefined Peter K

    I tried to jog to Dufferin once. I had to stop at Spadina.

  • http://undefined torontosean

    looks great!

  • http://undefined Martin Reis

    Nice design if you agree that cars rule in this town.

  • http://undefined Martin Reis

    As for Pantalone he runs the CNE and then some
    http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2009/cc/bgrd/mm41.7.pdf
    The Dufferin Jog has long been a pet project of his.

  • Darren

    Its for the Dufferin buses and Queen cars too. They are on the road as well
    Now hopefully the cops will actually enforce the charging of cyclists who ride on the sidewalk under the bridge/s

  • Darren

    Yeah he flushed a million bucks literally down the toiler at the CNE

  • http://undefined Darren
  • http://paul.kishimoto.name Paul Kishimoto

    Here we see the word “literally” being violently abused.

  • http://undefined Darren

    Yeah Paul, because the CTF has nothing more to do then chace useless causes. How dare they try to be an impartial spokesperson of how our (once you leave UoF you might be part of that ‘our’) taxes??

  • http://undefined Vincent Clement

    So as a transit consumer, you won’t mind paying the full cost of running the TTC? Anything less is a waste of my taxes.

  • http://undefined Darren

    What part of my comment had anything to do with taxes going towards the TTC? Did you read the article about Pantalone? I dont think the TTC was mentioned once. This is the second time you’ve blindly responded to a comment of mine for no reason other then for the sake of doing so. Its borderline insane and stalkerish

  • http://undefined fantasygoat

    My studio used to be in the white industrial building right where the jog starts. It was a great space, because it was near Queen on Dufferin, but because of the jog, it was isolated and therefore rent was cheaper. It allowed me to offer low-cost access for artists who couldn’t afford all the equipment to do proper screenprinting.
    When they finally started construction, the landlord nearly doubled my rent, to the point where I simply couldn’t afford to stay there. Thanks to all the condo developments in the area, there isn’t anymore studio space left, so I was forced to close down. I wasn’t the only one, either – I know of at least four other small, artisan businesses in that building who were forced into the same predicament.
    He did this because now, the building will be well placed for all the new drive- and walk-by traffic the underpass will bring. It might even become another bland condo in the coming years.
    Don’t get me wrong – the underpass is a huge improvement to the area and will make traveling on Dufferin a million times easier and faster. I’m totally on-side. But at the same time, it’s one more nail in the coffin for the artistic community in the area, which is a shame.

  • http://undefined dowlingm

    This google maps aerial shot gives a good look at the scale of what’s being attempted here.
    I think it’s a mistake for streetcar track not to be laid through the construction zone now with a view to going further north as Dufferin undergoes road maintenance. Dundas is 1000m north of Dufferin/Queen (PDF) and addition of track and overhead to that point which would add resiliency to the north-of-Queen network but would also, among other things, allow the 193 Exhibition Rocket to be the new 28m streetcars not 13m buses.

  • http://undefined Darren

    Couldnt you just apply to get the government fund space in the old streetcar barns at Whyvchwood?
    I cant think of one other industry that gets government funded business space.

  • http://undefined Darren

    Why do people suggest streetcars as being the future look of this city for ever and ever and ever??
    That intersection is the likely location of the western part of the DRL. We should be asking why the infrastructure isnt being laid for a subway, and not a streetcar. This is 2010, not 1910. We need the DRL more then we need any extension of the Y/U/S line.

  • http://undefined dowlingm

    1. The YUS extensions are happening and you need to adjust your reality accordingly. I don’t like the fact that the Spadina extension north of Steeles was built to buy votes in Vaughan but that’s where we are. Should the subway go to Richmond Hill GO right now? No, the GO Train should be increased but there is almost certainly going to be a partial extension to Steeles to keep them placated and prevent Finch from being overrun once LRTs start arriving.
    2. Even if funding materialised in the morning it will take a decade to plan and build even a partial DRL because the dense above and below ground forms and utilities (some almost certainly unmapped) in that area make the challenge of the YUS extensions seem laughably simple, not to mention that there is no agreement in the community as to route through the core – some pushing for Queen (incl. me), some Richmond or Adelaide or Wellington or King.
    3. If commitment was made by the TTC a Dundas West-Dufferin route could be operational far more quickly, reducing the number of buses required in the area, using a route for which 75% of the track already exists west of Dundas/Dufferin and south of Queen/Dufferin.

  • Darren

    Dowlingm, thats what makes todays city planners useless compared to the ones in the past. The designer of the Bloor Viaduct designed it with a section underneath for a subway years before the Bloor line even existed.

  • http://www.newmindspace.com Kevin Bracken

    Surprised nobody mentioned the ads in the tunnel

  • http://undefined Darren

    Those are pictures depicting the history of the intersecton as well as art

  • http://undefined theforgottencylon

    How much is this project costing? $30 million, $40 million?
    The City is cutting all over the place, child care centres may close, etc. etc.
    Yet these super-expensive “transportation” department projects get no scrutiny whatsoever. Perks and Giambrone are going to have a hard time explaining their waste of public funds — for what? Research has shown that most of the traffic on Dufferin is actually from outside Toronto, a large percentage from Mississauga.
    We’re losing city services so that “motorists” from Mississauga can scoot straight up Dufferin?
    What a sad joke.

  • http://undefined Vincent Clement

    What subway infrastructure would you put there? Just wondering.

  • http://undefined Darren

    Vincent, I dont know the exact specifics. From similiar ‘planned ahead’ infrastructures like the ones that were mandated by city planners in the past on Queen west of Yonge to just past Uni, it involved designating that area a space where utilities had to be under the sidewalk or close to the sidewalk. The middle of the street is void of utilities. They also required buildings being built along that stretch to have their foundations encassed in a rubber shock absorbent system to reduce the effects of a subway running close by.
    If I had to guess the stretch of Queen under the bridge could have also been dug up while the work was being done, with the foundations lowered to the depth of a subway tunnel and then the area backfilled to its original grade and the street resurfaced. If a subway was ever required under Queen street machinery can then removed the backfill without any threat of weakening the foundations.

  • http://undefined Darren

    Its also fair to point out that streetcars are not as ‘clean’ as many believe. There is the obvious generation of electricity by coal, but also the large amount that is lost in the grid just getting it to the individual cars. All circuits and wires have a certain level on inefficiency and the longer the grid is the more electricity is lost. But there is also the energy used to construct the track and the amount of chemicals used to clean the tracks. The TTC fleet of streetcars use a mixture of salt/sand all year long which is dropped on the wheels for traction. They then have to send out crews periodically on white pickups who stop traffic while they clean out the accumilation of this gunk from the switches.
    This whole endevour to me is similiar to probably what was required to maintain horse drawn carriages and the people hired to clean the byproduct of those horses from the streets

  • http://www.flickriver.com/photos/doitintheroad/ dcooper

    Having suffered Dufferin 29, commuting the entire route from Dufferin & Wilson to Duff & King for years, I can attest to the TTC nightmare the jog entails. Not to say that many other parts of Dufferin are much cleaner (they’re not), but just take a look at the extra work the jog creates for those buses. In fact, you can see three TTC buses caught in the mess in the Google Sat view (one turning under the bridge, one on Queen, one on Gladstone).
    I’ve since moved on from my Dufferin days, but I will say: Hurrah for the new Duffnnel!
    (One thing it needs: a catchy nickname. Soon.)

  • http://undefined Vincent Clement

    They could just as easily extend the foundations when the final corridor for the DRL is chosen. Better, they could likely build a subway station at the time. Why dig up Queen Street twice?

  • http://undefined Darren

    Thats my point. Do it now instead of later