Today Fri Sat
It is forcast to be Clear at 10:00 PM EST on February 09, 2012
Clear
4°/-1°
It is forcast to be Mostly Cloudy at 10:00 PM EST on February 10, 2012
Mostly Cloudy
5°/-9°
It is forcast to be Partly Cloudy at 10:00 PM EST on February 11, 2012
Partly Cloudy
1°/-5°

11 Comments

news

Temporary Deforestation on Bloor Street

20091216treesonbloor2.jpg
Passersby on the portion of Bloor Street just south of Yorkville are in for an unnerving sight. The stretch of road between Yonge Street and Avenue Road that last week was lined with trees in sidewalk planters is now decked by long rows of tree stumps. The clear-cut is a result of the ongoing Bloor Street Transformation Project, which will see sidewalks on Bloor Street between Church Street and Avenue Road widened and paved with granite, and new planters for trees and flowers installed. New trees will be planted to replace the ones that have just been chopped down.


The replacement planting is scheduled to be completed in 2011, according to a recent newsletter from the Bloor-Yorkville BIA [PDF]. In the meantime, the sight of so many decapitated trees—some, as of yesterday, left uprooted and sitting askew in their planters—might seem alarming to anyone with an attachment to Toronto’s urban forest. It’s as though a crew of crazed lumberjacks convened on the spot and went on an arboreal killing spree. In reality, the trees are a casualty of progress. They’ve merely taken one for the team.
20091216treesonbloor1.jpg
The sad, dilapidated sight stands in contrast to the moneyed boutiques that front on the affected sidewalk. Louis Vuitton, Cartier, and Prada all have shops there, to name just a few. The giant green Christmas tree in front of the William Ashley store in the Manulife Centre, a temporary decoration and not a part of the transformation, is practically the last tree standing in the area, with the exception of a trio of trees just west of the intersection of Bloor and Yonge streets, already planted as part of the project by construction workers earlier this year.
Construction on the transformation project began in 2008, between Yonge and Church streets, and renovation on that section of road is already nearly complete. Fifty-eight new London Plane trees have been planted there, in granite planters. The planters are outfitted with what the Bloor-Yorkville BIA website refers to, impressively, as “innovative and sustainable soil cell systems.” These cells are so-called Silva Cells, and are designed to allow tree roots to spread relatively unfettered underneath pavement.
The design for the project, developed by architectsAlliance and Brown + Storey Architects, and funded jointly by the city and by members of the Bloor-Yorkville BIA, calls for eighty more of the new trees to be planted, most of which will be placed west of Yonge Street, to replace those that were just chopped down. For now, though, Bloor Street denizens will need to put up with a bleak, treeless winter streetscape. Not that it wouldn’t have been bleak, anyhow.
Photos by Remi Carreiro/Torontoist.
Hat tip to Martin Reis.

Comments

  • http://undefined sukalalee

    Seriously? They literally planted those tress about a month ago. What a waste.

  • http://stevekupferman.typepad.com Steve Kupferman

    All the newly planted trees east of Yonge Street are still there. Only the older trees west of Yonge were cut down.

  • http://undefined Svend

    They were sad starving trees. I’m glad they’re going to plant them more intelligently now but I doubt they’ll be healthy.
    What about the post and rings, are they still going to be removed? I know the businesses didn’t like the idea of unsightly bicycles on public spaces in front of their stores.

  • http://undefined Usus

    A lot on Bay street have been cut to the trunk also, I assume it’s because they died. The city was supposed to have a new system to keep trees healthy but it doesn’t seem to have worked.

  • http://undefined andrews

    I’d be a bit upset — if the trees had a fighting chance of surviving until next summer. Big if. Left to their own devices they’d be crotch-height stumps by June anyways.
    I’m curious as to how long the trees in their innovative new whachamacallit planters last before they too go to the big woodchipper in the sky? It’s a good question: how much innovation does it take to make up for a month of neglect?

  • http://undefined Martin Reis

    Thankfully Google Streets View remembers … http://is.gd/5p5S7

  • http://undefined Mistro

    Shiva Cells? Isn’t that what that super virus that was supposed to kill everyone was called in Tom Clancy’s novel Rainbow Six?
    Well hopefully the new trees are well maintained.

  • http://undefined Rachel Lissner

    Bravo on that first photo! I like how the photographer managed to divide the street and sidewalk with the tape.

  • http://undefined jonny

    The real tragedy is that the city refuses to let trees along the streets grow to maturity… wouldn’t want to upset the narrow minded retailers now would we?

  • http://undefined Tbotinator

    Plane Trees are a poor choice for Toronto.

  • http://undefined Martin Reis

    Update: December 22. The clearcut continues on the south side of Bloor over to Yonge Street. A dozen more trees were chopped in half. Sad. A took some more pics …
    http://www.flickr.com/photos/martinreis/4207017176/in/set-72157623006406302/