Tip Us Off
E-mail us with news tips, discoveries, story ideas, and anything else cool.
Advertisements

About Torontoist

Torontoist is a website about Toronto and everything that happens in it. More about us.

Editor-in-Chief: DAVID TOPPING

Publisher: GOTHAMIST

What's On Today
Check out Torontoist's daily event listings
Recent Comments
The Tall Poppy Interview
Favourites

May 29, 2008

Email This Entry







Advertisement: Torontoist Continues Below!

Comments (8) [rss]

How exactly is a border guard supposed to determine that the MP3 I have on my iPhone is from iTunes or from The Pirate Bay or anywhere else?

They all look the same in the interface. Same goes for songs on a PC - those without DRM have the same file extension as those that are ripped off a CD.

This is totally unenforceable. Unless you have folders of deeply nested downloads with "downloaded from Mininova" text files in them or whatever, there's really nothing that can be proven unless they confiscate your PC and do virtual forensics.

The precedent is scary though.

 

Scanning computers and mp3 players will add significantly to check-in times, as well and create a backlog. Think of all the business people who take flights on a regular basis every couple of months, with their laptops and blackberries and possibly mp3 players too.

 

The fact that Harper is completely going along with this, quietly in the backroom no less, doesn't surprise me in the least.

This has zero to do with the interest of Canadians, or even other countries' citizens, and 100% to do with Big American Media.

 

Of course there's a Facebook group: Get out of my iPod - No ACTA for Canada

 

mark0:

Think of all the business people who take flights on a regular basis every couple of months, with their laptops and blackberries and possibly mp3 players too.

I doubt the suits are the ones who'll be searched.

 

rival oms:

What about the hipster professionals that dress all business-raggedy and ride their vintage bikes really slowly along Queen West?

...yes I do like commuting quickly.

 

Maybe they'll only let DRMed files across the border, or files which match certain DRM-free, but still payed for, file hashes.

It would be a hassle for sites that offer legal downloads to comply with this by sending in hashes of all of their files of course.

 

For folks concerned about both copyright and net neutrality, the NDP has been the most active party in the House of Commons. Below are some links so you can find out what the NDP has been doing:

WIPO REALITY CHECK: NDP OFFERS PRENTICE A WAY THROUGH COPYRIGHT MORASS
http://www.charlieangus.net/newsitem.php?id=301
http://www.ndp.ca/page/3725
http://www.charlieangus.net/newsitem.php?id=324

NET NEUTRALITY
http://www.ndp.ca/page/6326
http://www.charlieangus.net/newsitem.php?id=331
http://www.charlieangus.net/newsitem.php?id=318
http://www.charlieangus.net/newsitem.php?id=315
http://www.charlieangus.net/newsitem.php?id=314
http://www.charlieangus.net/newsitem.php?id=311

 
Post a comment (Comment Policy)

2003-2008 Gothamist LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. We use MovableType.