Tip Us Off
E-mail us with news tips, discoveries, story ideas, and anything else cool.
Advertisements

About Torontoist

Torontoist is a website about Toronto and everything that happens in it. More about us.

Editor-in-Chief: DAVID TOPPING

Publisher: GOTHAMIST

What's On Today
Check out Torontoist's daily event listings
Recent Comments
The Tall Poppy Interview
Favourites

February 1, 2008

Jarvis Slip Design Winner Revealed

sugarbeach1.jpg

The verdict is in, and the umbrellas are going up! Following an invited competition to design a new public space for the Jarvis Slip, Waterfront Toronto has revealed the winner, unanimously chosen by the design jury: Claude Cormier Architectes Paysagistes Inc.

As outlined in our competition coverage, the Cormier plan—dubbed "Sugar Beach"—will bring an HtO Park-style "urban beach" to the foot of Jarvis Street, dotted with charming steel umbrellas and Muskoka chairs. The sandy wedge sits directly across from the Redpath shipping basin, and also includes a pedestrian promenade and public plaza demarcating the western edge of the upcoming East Bayfront development. The East Bayfront site will eventually host five significant public spaces.

sugarbeach2.jpg

Sugar Beach is based on Cormier's quirky HtO Park, co-designed with Jarvis Slip competitor Janet Rosenberg + Associates. Unlike HtO Park's yellow canopies, the umbrellas at Sugar Beach will be multi-coloured—what Waterfront Toronto calls "candy coated," which is appropriate considering the troublesome sugar dust blowing off the Redpath factory. Results from a dust and emissions study haven't yet been revealed, but 25–30 ships unload their raw sugar cargo annually from the west side of the slip, which takes about three days per boat. The design submissions were required to take the factory noise and wind-borne debris into consideration.

Canadian-sourced granite boulders will be assembled throughout the park, which the designers hope will serve as vantage points for waterfront events. Local trees will also populate the site, with granite tiles paving the plaza section. A continuous promenade will split the beach and plaza in half at an angle, extending from Queen's Quay East down to the waterfront boardwalk (the trees and paving along the dockside promenade are part of the existing Waterfront Revitalization Plan and had to remain consistent in materials and design). The plaza will border on the new studios of Corus Entertainment, to be built in TEDCO's upcoming First Waterfront Place.

sugarbeach3.jpg

No mention was made about a proposed "moon lighting" tower in today's announcement, although New York-based lighting designer Leni Schwendinger was part of the design team and also created the appealing lighting scheme for HtO Park. The group is rounded out by David Leinster, landscape architect with the Planning Partnership, and design consultant and author Beth Kapusta, both from Toronto. Landscape architect Claude Cormier has an obvious knack for combining natural and industrial environments, helming projects like Old Montreal's Place d'Youville and Lipstick Forest, Shanghai's Montreal Garden, and the Don Valley Brick Works restoration.

The city's second dockside beach may not be its last, according to jury member Siamak Hariri: "The jury appreciated the big idea approach for the design of Jarvis Slip with its connectivity and integration to the central waterfront promenade design, and the proposal for the establishment of a larger greater system of beach designs throughout Toronto's waterfront." Strangely, Hariri also claims that the jury panel wants to see the signature umbrellas entirely removed from the final installation.

The $4 million project is slated to begin construction in the spring of 2009, and will be complete the following year.

sugarbeach4_01.jpgsugarbeach4_02.jpg


Email This Entry







Advertisement: Torontoist Continues Below!

Comments (6)

Delicious!

Though, sadly, the wonderful design here only underlines the missed opportunity HtO was to create something TRULY brilliant.

City Hall shouldn't have shied away from extending the decking at HtO directly into the water (due to liability concerns). While this could be a feature of Sugar Beach, it isn't anywhere near as appropriate as at HtO site (not many folks are comfortable swimming near a ship).

Let's hope the Sherbourne Street park plan has something in the way of direct water access so Torontonians can truly reconnect with their waterfront.

 

The Corel Broadcasting Building. Now Sugar Beach. What a dismal start for the lake shore. If the rest of it is this awful, I can't imagine anyone will WANT to reconnect with the waterfront.


 

ps: Apparently they -- whoever they is -- decided to shelve the only appealing element to the " beach, " the umbrella's.

 

Also note that Waterfront Toronto rejected the latest design for First Waterfront Place in December after the most recent plans put forward by TEDCO didn't jive with the conditional approval granted in the summer. Many of the positive aspects of the design, like granite columns and the floating "egg" conference room, were removed...so, basically, TEDCO got tentative approval on one design, then cut corners and cheapened it down into something architecturally less significant and expected that they were going to be allowed to continue.

Apparently, however, First Waterfront Place is now being allowed to go forward with the cheapened version, and the iconic umbrellas might be nixed. At least Toronto is consistent in its perpetual ability to disappoint.

 

That's why we should stop calling this city world class - we just don't deserve it...

 

Experience world class disappointment in Toronto. The town that fun forgot.


 
Post a comment (Comment Policy)

2003-2008 Gothamist LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. We use MovableType.