Tip Us Off
E-mail us with news tips, discoveries, story ideas, and anything else cool.
Advertisements

About Torontoist

Torontoist is a website about Toronto and everything that happens in it. More about us.

Editor-in-Chief: DAVID TOPPING

Publisher: GOTHAMIST

What's On Today
Check out Torontoist's daily event listings
Recent Comments
The Tall Poppy Interview
Favourites

December 6, 2007

The Onion Picks on Toronto's Poor

1007_12_05JasonJones.jpgMany of you may remember 25-year old Jason Jones, who was on the front page of the Toronto Star last February as a graphic indictment against "the miserable state of dental care for our working poor." The resulting outcry led to demands that the indigent and working poor have better access to dental care.

Jones' story had a happy ending: offers poured in from readers to help pay for the dental work he desperately needed, and Dr. Raj Singh offered to fit the sweet-natured husband and father for dentures free of charge. The results were dramatic, revealing the fresh-faced, attractive young man who had previously been obscured.

So, it was a surprise to find Jones' "before" photo crop up again in the news, this time on the main page of the parody newspaper The Onion. Presented with three other individuals under the headline "30 Miserable Lives Lost in Greyhound Crash", the photo is followed by the caption, "Four degenerate sacks of shit who perished in the accident."

The article, which satirizes the media's disaster coverage (as well as Greyhound riders), appears to have chosen Jones (shown in bottom left) to help illustrate the "deadbeat dads and penniless addicts" who mercifully died in the crash. At one point the article reads, "dental records have helped identify only two-thirds of the casualties, as the remaining 10 passengers were discovered to have none of their original teeth left."

Ironically, shortly after the Star's original article, the newspaper followed up with a video of Jason Jones describing the difficulty he actually had finding a job because of his appearance.

Since Torontoist discovered this photo late Wednesday afternoon, Jones' image from the Onion story has been replaced with a photo of a grizzled older man.

Thanks to Jonathan Goldsbie for the proactive image grab.


Email This Entry







Advertisement: Torontoist Continues Below!

Comments (8)

They probably did a Google image search for "ugly dude" or "toothless guy" and used whatever they came up with. Am I missing something? The Onion isn't picking on Toronto's poor in the linked story at all, as your title suggests.

 

Thanks to Torontoist for pointing out what callow writers often forget: that things like bus crashes are real events; that real people are attached to the random images generated by a Google search; that when those unaffected by tragedies make a joke of them they display a lamentable lack of compassion.

 

Accidentally picking on, maybe.

 

they changed the graphic.

 

Among other things, that was copyright infringement by the Onion.

 

That would really ruin your day.

 

I bet it was a Google image search as well, and the article was in terrible taste and wasn't even funny.

Writers for commercial web sites (like the Onion) can not just use Google image searches not only due to copyright issues, but the possibility of using the wrong image. For an example, the people for the GTAA's new website (Metrolinx) used Google image searches for GTA cities, and used a copyrighted Toronto skyline mock-up of the future (including Trump Tower) and used images of the wrong Brampton and Pickering.

 

Isn't it possible that The Onion subscribes to a news photo database?

 
Post a comment (Comment Policy)

2003-2008 Gothamist LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. We use MovableType.