Today Sat Sun
It is forcast to be Thunderstorm at 11:00 PM EDT on May 25, 2012
Thunderstorm
31°/17°
It is forcast to be Partly Cloudy at 11:00 PM EDT on May 26, 2012
Partly Cloudy
22°/18°
It is forcast to be Mostly Cloudy at 11:00 PM EDT on May 27, 2012
Mostly Cloudy
22°/15°

10 Comments

news

Reality Check

2007_03_19secret.jpgIt was only inevitable; indeed, they would say we asked for it. The Secret, the latest in a long line of mega-selling self-help phenomena, is on its way to Toronto. Several “teachers” featured in the original film and the subsequent book will be holding forth on April 14th and 15th at the Westin Harbour Castle. The promotional literature is distinguished by its modest proposal: “The Secret to everything—the secret to life filled with joy, good health, financial freedom, loving relationships, abundant energy, youth: everything you ever wanted.” Profundity and provocation are sure to be the order of the day.
It’s really all very simple; the consumer wouldn’t have it any other way. The Secret’s million-dollar answer to the age-old question of how to get what we want: “Ask. Believe. Receive.” And what makes this mind-over-matter jujitsu possible—”the law of attraction.” Of course, this isn’t the same thing as gravity, or the strong nuclear force, nor does it feature in the laws of thermodynamics, but if you think it … doesn’t it make it so? So argue the all star cast of self-help gurus that Rhonda Byrne, the film’s producer and the book’s editor, has gathered together in what is ultimately a hodgepodge of new age mumbo-jumbo.
Positive thinking and visualizaion, such are the rigorous requirements of future prosperity. If you put out the right thoughts and the right energy, the law of the universe dictates that whatever you so desire shall be yours. That this is the quintessence of cliché, almost goes without saying. Not to be outdone, The Secret “teachers” insist that this message, this “law of attraction”, is timeless. Indeed, they maintain that, among others, Plato, Shakespeare, Newton, Beethoven, Einstein, Martin Luther King and Andrew Carnegie were privy to the law – hence their success, or something.
All this shouldn’t trouble us so much, after all The Da Vinci Code was simply too inane to rock the boats of Christianity or art history. At the same time, the massive phenomenon that is The Secret, receiving glowing acclaim from Oprah Winfrey, does point toward a more pernicious trend. In fact, The Secret’s proposed modus operandi calls to mind a now infamous New York Times Magazine article by Ron Suskind, in which he relates a conversation he had with an aide to George W. Bush. The most telling passage reads: “The aide said that guys like me were ‘in what we call the reality-based community,’ which he defined as people who ‘believe that solutions emerge from your judicious study of discernible reality.’ … ‘That’s not the way the world really works anymore,’ he continued. ‘We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you’re studying that reality—judiciously, as you will—we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out. We’re history’s actors . . . and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.’” Ergo Iraq.
Poverty, political strife, ecological collapse, rebellious teens, cheating spouse? Create your own reality. Just do it. By now such postmodern pieties are formulaic: equal parts obscurantism and banality. In their stead, how about this secret for self-improvement. Charles Taylor, Canada’s preeminent philosopher and emeritus professor at McGill, was recently awarded the prestigious Templeton Prize for Progress Toward Research or Discoveries about Spiritual Realities, itself not without its detractors. In any case, Taylor has authored a number of essential texts, including Hegel and Sources of the Self, not to mention his remarkable collection of Massey Lectures, The Malaise of Modernity. The gulf between the respective wisdom of Taylor’s work and that of The Secret and their respective sales is as good an index you need of a society in thrall to all things lite.
“Ask. Believe. Receive.” Oh yeah, and buy our book.

Comments

  • Working From Home Today

    I see your point. It certainly made Rhonda Byrne rich and there are haunting implications in the White House.
    But I’ve read The Secret, watched The Secret. I’ve also listened to Charles Taylor. Guess which one motivated me more?
    Sometimes simplicity is more effective. Finding sources of inspiration is not always a rational pursuit.
    The Secret and various other ‘lite’ sources, including this song currently playing on my iPod (which you would most likely label as drivel), simply makes me feel good.
    And anything that shifts the malaise is like a miracle drug. If it’s Charles Taylor for you, bravo.

  • Jeff Hume

    I work at a Chapters and I cannot tell you how much I hate this book.
    Customer: “Hi, I’m looking for this book.”
    Me: (thinking, no really?) “What are you looking for?”
    Customer: “It’s called The Secret”
    Me: “We’re sold out unfortunately”
    Customer: “Oh, do you know when you’ll get it back in?”
    Me: “I can’t really say, the publisher is printing them as fast as they can.”
    At which point the customer proceeds to tell me about how they heard the book was so good and will change your life.

  • rek

    I’d never heard of it before now — now that’s a secret.

  • Sean Galbraith

    Martin Luther King Jr was murdered. I wonder how that fits into their theory.

  • Mike Gannon

    I love to read how pursuasive, close-minded, jounalistic idiots spout their sense of rationality for all their readers to adopt as the vigilant truth of “what is.” Clearly this journalist likes to impress you with his heavy laden lexicon and leave you with the impression that his written intellect eguals profound wisdom. No, clearly in this instance, that would not be the case. If he had any knowledge of science, particulary in the field of quantum physics, he would not be writing such a foolish piece. The problem with our media nowadays is we are hearing the news defined by the limitations of the reporters belief system and opinions – not by the actual facts or science or indisputable truth. Gravity is an indisputable truth, so is quantum physics. It has been here since the beginning of time. The law of attraction is simply a generic phrase, a label that defines and identifies in simplistic terms what we are all a part of in our every waking moment. Rhonda Byrne should be credited for bringing to our awareness something we can use on conscious level, with deliberate intent, instead of continually playing the victim to life happenstance. We are the ones that make our choices in life in everything we do. Our choices all lead to an inevitable consequence, therefore, where we direct our thoughts (which is by quantum nature – energy) will determine what we attract into our lives. I invite all of you who read this piece to further explore how everything, as proven by scientific research is energy, (Einstien proved this) and how the fundamental law “Like thoughts attract like consequences.” As a deaf man, I have spent my whole life witnessing how my thoughts have affected my reality time and again, I like to think experientially I can lend some credibility to this argument. I think you will feel a bit more empowered in giving the law of attraction an authentic try rather than jumping on the band wagon of some ignorant, opiniated, limiting point of view. But remember this, because of the law of polarity, just like learning the game of golf, in the beginning you are going find yourself hitting the ball in some undesirable places. Likewise, in the game of the Law of Attraction, you will attract some undesirable consequences when you first get started. Take it as a learning and do not be quick to say, “See, it doesn’t work.” Good luck!

  • joncormier

    I’ve seen this as both book and DVD, I believe, in people’s hands. I had no idea what it was until now.
    I sort of thought it was this story set in colonial America about a woman who falls in love with someone of lower class or has a divorce and was made into some movie that plays at the local arthouse cinema. I think I’ll continue to imagine it as some mash-up of The Scarlet Letter and Lady Chatterly’s Lover instead of yet another self help epi-phenomenon. What happened to hating carbs?

  • andrew

    If you feel this works for you, great. Fantastic! I’m envious of the success you will achieve. But I’m pretty sure that for every person who manages to use these theorems for personal gain successfully, there are at least ten who are frantically applying themselves to it and getting nothing. Indeed, they are out the cost of buying the book, or dvd, or attending the seminars. And I refuse, I absolutely refuse, to countenance any theory of “making life better for you” that is taught by people who make their living off of it, in a way that is ostentatiously wealthy. Hey, buddhist monks do it with begging bowls, and it’s much the same frigging message.

  • Justin

    GREAT article about The Secret (specifically Oprah’s promotion of it) on Salon.
    (can’t use the link – find it yourself)
    “Secret”-style belief is a perfect product. Like Coca-Cola, it goes down easy and makes the consumer thirsty for more. It’s unthreateningly simple, and a lot more facile, sentimental and, perhaps paradoxically, intractable than the old-fashioned kind of belief. Like Amway, it enlists its consumers as unofficial salespeople, and the people who constitute its market feel like they’re part of a fold. It’s indistinguishable from, and inextricably bound up in, the Oprah idea of self-esteem, the kind of confidence you get not from testing yourself, but from “believing” in yourself. This modern idea of faith isn’t arrived at the old-fashioned way, by asking questions, but by getting answers. Instead of inquiry we have born-again epiphanies and cheesy self-help books — we have excuses for not engaging in inquiry at all. Let other people schlep down the road to Damascus; we’ll have Amazon send Damascus to us.”
    As to the people that are thinking of buying the book or DVD of ‘The Secret’ – let me save you the money:
    “Be the change you want to see in the world”
    Read Dickens, watch The Wire, go see a play, volunteer with kids or old people. Your problem isn’t that you ‘can’t envision yourself happy,’ it’s that you’re (we’re) so incredibly self-centered.
    Anyway great post, Chris.

  • Tlönista

    Thanks, Torontoist, for the dose of common sense!
    What happens and what we would like to happen are, in general, only incidentally the same. You’d think more people would have figured this out.

  • Boy Reporter

    Heh… I wanted George W. Bush to get hit by a bus. But that hasn’t happened yet. Should I call Ms. Byrne and ask for my money back?